4. Issues of Ethnopharmacology in HIV Management
Hispanic Americans
Hispanics of various ethnic and cultural backgrounds—particularly more recent arrivals to the United States—sometimes patronize botanicos, which are stores that sell traditional herbal medicines and related items. Botanicos and related medical practices often provide a treatment approach for individuals who either do not want allopathic treatments or who do not have access to them. For some people, botanicos may also provide a complement to allopathic treatments. For these reasons, botanicos can serve as focal points for obtaining treatment and information in Hispanic communities. In addition, the staff at botanicos provide services and merchandise that are considered to support a more holistic approach to health issues—ie, one that regards health as a network of physical, emotional, and spiritual factors. [Anderson 2008, DeStefano 2001, Zacharias 2006, Ortiz 2008; Santiago-Saavedra 2004]
Studies have reported that a substantial proportion of HIV-positive Hispanic patients seek treatment at botanicos. [Chang 2003, Josephs 2007, Ladenheim 2008, Rivera 2006, Rivera 2005] Ortiz and colleagues reported that patients often feel that curanderos offer supportive encounters that they do not receive from allopathic practitioners. [Ortiz 2007] In addition, some patients—typically ones having lower income, less English proficiency, and less formal education [Mikhail 2004, Gomez-Beloz 2001]—seek care at botanicos because they lack access to conventional healthcare services. [Zacharias 2006]
Drug interactions.
Studies have indicated that some remedies supplied by botanicos can reduce HIV-related symptoms and adverse treatment effects—eg, herbs such as dragon’s blood (Sanguis dracona), which has been shown to reduce diarrhea. [DeStefano 2001] However, some Hispanic folk healing practices can have negative interactions with allopathic medicines. For example, St. John’s Wort (called “hyperico” in most botanicos), which is commonly recommended for depression or anxiety, can decrease the effectiveness of protease inhibitors. [Hennessey 2002, Henderson 2002, Winston 2005] Clinical doses of garlic may have the same effect. [Piscitelli 2002, Winston 2005]
Collaboration and education.
The most productive approach to addressing patients’ needs may come through collaboration between folk healers and conventional healthcare practitioners. For example, botanicos and curanderos may be trained to recognize situations in which conventional medical care is needed; likewise, conventional providers should be aware of their Hispanic patients’ use of botanicos and related practices and their effects. This will require not only training of the folk healers but also cultural competence education and practice for conventional providers, so that they can better understand Hispanic patients’ beliefs and practices regarding health and sickness and how they communicate and make decisions about health. For example, patients and healthcare practitioners may emphasize different symptoms, use different terminology to describe symptoms or treatments, or provide different explanations for the mechanisms of an illness and its treatment. [Loera 2009, DeStefano 2001] When clinicians communicate with their patients and alternative-care providers to understand and overcome such differences, they will be better able to provide evidence-based care that treats HIV disease by incorporating the patients’ perspective, which may see healing as a spiritual and emotional process, as well as a physical one.
Collaborating with botanicos staff, curanderos, and others can demonstrate healthcare providers’ respect for and understanding of a community’s traditions and perspectives on health and healing and can help to address patients’ critical spiritual and psychological needs. On the other hand, educating community members and their traditional healers about conventional medicine may encourage more people to access conventional services and enhance HIV treatment outcomes in Hispanic communities.