4. Issues of Ethnopharmacology in HIV Management
Ethnopharmacology Practices Employed Among Diverse Populations
African Americans
The use of CAM has long held an important place in African American communities, and much of it is related to folk healing traditions, such as home remedies, herbal medicine, nutrition, and root work. [Gunn 2011, Mathews 1987, Becerra 1995] (Root work involves the use of herbs, stones, roots, and other organic materials to cure the body, heal the mind, or solve a problem. Plants and animal parts are typically ground into powders or liquefied and combined with other materials to make treatments.[Asante 2004]) However, a 2006 study by Kelly and colleagues revealed that such practices have declined in recent years and that the prevalence of the use of herbs and other natural supplements was lowest among African Americans, at 9.5%, vs 12% among Hispanics and 19% among non-Hispanic whites. (The prevalence among Asian/Pacific Islanders and Native Americans was 14% and 16%, respectively.) [Kelly 2006]
Cultural context.
A history of slavery, oppression, and poverty meant that many African Americans lacked access to conventional medical care and therefore developed their own healing traditions using readily available herbs, foodstuffs, and other substances. [Barnett 2003] The beliefs and practices that evolved during that time continue to exert significant influence in today’s African American communities—and they are reflected in the healthcare-seeking behaviors that focus on self-care and control of the individual’s own experiences. [Like 2011, Hewins-Maroney 2005] Medical anthropologist EJ Bailey has suggested this definition of African-American alternative medicine: “African-American alternative medicine consists of believing in and/or using 'natural' and/or 'supernatural' treatment therapies that will significantly contribute to the healing process within a holistic, familial, and socioeconomic setting.” [Bailey 2002]
Although the use of traditional or folk remedies appears to be less common among younger African Americans, cultural beliefs related to those practices continue to affect African-Americans’ perceptions of health and healthcare-seeking behaviors.[Barnett 2003, Hewins-Maroney 2005] One critical feature is distrust of the healthcare system, which has sometimes provided inadequate or even harmful care to African Americans. [Barnett 2003, Bailey 2002] A serious consequence of such distrust is the communications barrier that it fosters between patients and practitioners. Understanding CAM practices in African American communities can serve as an entry point for improved communication and development of treatment plans. [Like 2011, Hekler 2008, Barnes 2008]
The expense of conventional medical care also serves as a driver of the use of CAM among African Americans, who comprise a disproportionate number of Americans who lack health insurance coverage. [AHRQ 2008] This can lead to delays in seeking medical care until a health condition has become severe or chronic—eg, using cheaper alternative treatments if prescribed medications are considered too costly. [Mackenzie 2002] Yet another driver in the use of CAM among African Americans is the need to seek relief from the adverse effects of allopathic treatments, such as chemotherapy.
Developing cultural competence.
In general, African Americans who use various forms of CAM believe that doing so is empowering, in terms of allowing them to retain greater control of their own healthcare, particularly when clinician-prescribed treatments lead to difficult adverse effects. Practitioners who invest the time and effort to understand not only the CAM modalities used by their African American patients but also the cultural context in which those practices exist can promote greater integration of self-care practices into conventional healthcare practices and can help patients develop better-informed medical decision making, particularly with regard to chronic conditions such as HIV disease. [Bailey 2002]