5. Culturally Competent Care for Substance Users Diagnosed with HIV Disease
Relationship Between Substance Use and Mental Disorders
According to data from the National Institute on Drug Abuse, [NIDA Comborbid Drug Abuse-2007] 60% of persons who have a substance use disorder also have some form of mental disorder, although the direction of causality can be complex. Which disorder preceded the other can vary from one person to another:
- Substance abuse can cause a mental illness.
- A mental disorder can lead to
substance abuse. - Substance abuse and mental disorders may both originate from other common risk factors.
- In some individuals, each of these scenarios may contribute to the development of a particular pattern of comorbid substance use and mental disorder.
Compared with the general population, patients with mood or anxiety disorders are about twice as likely to have a substance use disorder, and patients with substance use disorders are approximately twice as likely to be diagnosed with mood or anxiety disorders. The rates of specific comorbidities vary by gender, with antisocial personality disorders more common in men and major depression, posttraumatic stress disorder, and other anxiety disorders more common in women. [JAMA, 2011].
In an analysis of HIV-positive substance users with mental disorders, Weaver and colleagues reported that only 33% of study participants received concurrent treatment for both mental disorders and substance use, even though they met the diagnostic criteria for both, with 26% receiving only mental health services, 15% receiving only substance use services, and 26% receiving no services. [Weaver 2008] The investigators further reported that concurrent receipt of both types of services was significantly lower among nonwhite and Hispanic participants. Not surprisingly, they concluded that utilization of mental health services and substance use treatment among HIV-positive substance users with mental disorders needs to be enhanced.